ABC News correspondent Gio Benitez, who identifies as homosexual and is “married” to a man, recently participated in the sacrament of confirmation at St. Paul the Apostle’s Church in New York City on Nov. 8. The event, which included holy communion from Rev. Eric Andrews, saw Benitez’s “husband” serve as his sponsor, with Fr. James Martin acting as a concelebrant.
Bishop Joseph Strickland, removed from his position in Tyler, Texas, in 2023 by the late Pope Francis, addressed the matter during the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops’ plenary assembly, highlighting the apparent willingness of some priests to defy church customs. “I don’t know how many of us have seen on the social media priests and others gathered, celebrating the confirmation of a man living with a man openly,” Strickland remarked, noting the involvement of Fr. Martin.
The Catholic Church’s stance on homosexual acts is described as “acts of grave depravity” and “intrinsically disordered,” with the Catechism emphasizing that homosexual persons must be “accepted with respect, compassion, and sensitivity.” However, those who regularly engage in sexual activity or are partners in committed homosexual relationships are excluded from holy communion and public ministries.
Cardinal George Pell, posthumously exonerated, emphasized that receiving the sacrament is an intensely personal matter between communicant and priest, stating that “it’s not a question of refusing homosexuals or someone who is homosexually oriented.” The rule applies to anyone engaging in practices contrary to Church teaching, including those openly living in adultery or declaring themselves active homosexuals.
During the USCCB discussion, Strickland raised concerns about Benitez’s public reception of holy communion while flanked by his “husband,” noting that “Here we are talking about doctrine.” The panel, focused on updated ethical and religious directives for Catholic health care services, did not address Strickland’s concern.
Strickland’s tenure as bishop of Tyler was marked by a reputation for directness, strong emphasis on Eucharistic devotion, and a willingness to challenge trends he believed risked undermining Catholic teaching.
